Pin Reaper: Wendy
What I Did: These cookies looked amazing, and the recipe looked simple enough. So I gather all of my supplies and get going. This recipe involves forming the cookie dough differently than most, so I was excited about it. Just one teeny little mis-step, however…
I mis-read the recipe and put in twice as much butter as was called for! How the heck did I do that?! Boo!
For the record, I tried again with the right amount of butter and while they turned out looking kinda like melty mutant peeps, they tasted great!
Next Time I Will: Oh boy. Next time I will not channel my inner Paula Deen! I will keep trying this cookie-forming method she mentions, as it is intriguing. Maybe my next batch I will not form like marshmallows, but more egg-shaped. Hmm.