Fail: Nutter Butter Nightmare Turkey Cupcakes

Pin Reaper: Kim Quint

Original Inspiration:

Pinterest Fail Nutter Butter Nightmare Turkey Cupcakes inspiration

What I Did: I thought it would be fun to make with the kids (9 and 6). I went solely off the memory of the picture, so I didn’t have the right ingredients.

My Result:

Pinterest Fail Nutter Butter Nightmare Turkey Cupcakes result

Next Time I Will: print the ingredients and recipe. We had a good laugh which was the best part.

Pinterest Fail Nutter Butter Nightmare Turkey Cupcakes storyboard


  1. Cindy

    Yes memory fails me everytime. lol But I think they are cute and you had fun with the kiddos making them and thats what matters.

  2. AA

    I think they look fine.

  3. Hannah

    I don’t think they’re too bad

  4. Evelyn

    I actually like yours better since they are so endearing.

  5. Jassie

    I think they looked fine, I had to check twice to make sure it said ‘fail’ and not ‘win’.

  6. cheryl

    I’m calling these a win. They have serious personality!

  7. Anonymous

    Yours looks more appetizing to me. The other one looks like someone carved and painted wax.

  8. Melissa

    Why are they so mad?! LoL

  9. Michaela O'Friel

    WOW! You call this a fail???? You’re HUMAN, the crafts are done by people who have OBVIOUSLY done it before and or professionals. I’d bet a limb yours taste better! Also, you tried and, in my opinion, SUCCEEDED.
    Laugh, get silly, for it’s meant to be FUN!!!
    Peace, Love and happiness! ❤✌🏻🌻

  10. Aubrey

    I made these too and they turned out super cute! The only problem I had was that I stored them in an airtight container and in the morning they were soggy! I’m sure if it is the humid climate where I live or the moisture of the fresh cupcakes.

Leave a Comment