Win: Pizza P-eye

Pin Reaper: Disney_Sam728


Original Inspiration:

Pinterest Fail Pizza P-Eye inspiration

What I Did: I wanted to make amazing party food for my annual Halloween party, and I thought a spooky pizza would fit the bill! I came across this on my Pinterest feed, and I knew I had to try it! The pizza was a plain cheese one that I purchased from Costco. I chopped the peppers, pepperoni, and olives. I used circular cookie cutters to shape the pupil and iris, and I just cut strips of pepper to look like veins. It came out of the oven perfectly and was a big hit!

My Result:

Pinterest Fail Pizza P-Eye result

Next Time I Will: Change nothing! I will definitely be making this pizza again!

Pinterest Fail Pizza P-Eye storyboard


  1. gail

    Definitely NOT a fail! 🙂

  2. Beth K.

    Your pizza looks great. I would not call this a fail at all1

Leave a Comment